The Pros and Cons of Cedar Shake Roofing & Siding for Hamptons Architecture
Cedar shake roofing and siding have become defining features of Hamptons architecture. From traditional coastal cottages to modern luxury builds, cedar delivers a warm, organic look that blends seamlessly with the natural landscape. Its texture, depth, and timeless character make it one of the most visually striking exterior materials available.
But cedar’s beauty comes with unique considerations, especially in coastal Long Island, where humidity, wind, and salt air all affect exterior durability. Before deciding whether cedar shakes are right for your home, it’s important to understand both the advantages and the limitations.
Below is a deeper look at the pros and cons of cedar shake roofing and siding, tailored specifically to Hamptons-area homes.
The Benefits of Cedar Shake for Roofing & Siding
1. A Timeless Hamptons Aesthetic
Few materials capture the essence of Hamptons architecture like cedar. Its natural grain, soft earth tones, and organic texture provide a level of craftsmanship and authenticity that synthetic materials can’t fully replicate.
Cedar pairs beautifully with:
Stone siding accents
White coastal trim
Modern black window framing
Fiber cement siding used in combination applications
Coastal landscaping and natural dune settings
2. Excellent Natural Insulation
Cedar is one of the best natural insulators among common exterior materials. It helps stabilize indoor temperatures by reducing heat loss in winter and limiting heat absorption in summer, an important benefit in the fluctuating climate of Suffolk County.
Cedar also works well alongside:
New home siding upgrades
Mixed-material exteriors optimized for energy efficiency
3. Strong Wind Resistance
Salt air and high winds are a part of daily life on the East End. Cedar shake roofing offers impressive durability against strong gusts because the material naturally flexes rather than cracking under stress.
When installed by an experienced roofing and siding contractor, cedar can outperform other materials in wind resistance, making it a smart choice for storm-prone coastal areas.
4. Premium, Natural, and Eco-Friendly
As a biodegradable and renewable material, cedar appeals to homeowners who prefer sustainable building options. Many cedar shakes are sourced from responsibly managed forests, making them an environmentally conscious choice.
This aligns well with the architectural preference in the Hamptons for materials that feel rooted in nature rather than synthetic or overly industrial.
The Drawbacks of Cedar Shake Roofing & Siding
1. Higher Maintenance Requirements
Cedar’s beauty comes with a maintenance commitment. To preserve its color, structure, and resistance to moisture, homeowners often need to:
Seal or stain the cedar periodically
Remove moss or mildew
Replace individual shakes over time
Monitor moisture exposure near shaded or tree-covered areas
Compared to vinyl siding, fiber cement siding, or modern composite materials, cedar requires more upkeep.
2. Sensitivity to Moisture
Coastal humidity can accelerate cedar weathering if the material isn’t properly maintained. Without the right care, cedar shakes may:
Darken unevenly
Warp or cup
Absorb excess moisture
Show early signs of rot
Professional installation and routine maintenance are key to keeping cedar performing at its best.
3. Higher Upfront Cost
Cedar shakes typically cost more than vinyl siding, asphalt shingles, or even some fiber cement siding options. That said, many homeowners choose cedar for its unmatched aesthetics and premium feel, viewing it as a long-term investment in curb appeal.
4. Natural Color Change Over Time
Some homeowners love the silver-gray patina cedar develops as it ages; others prefer the warm, freshly installed tone. If you want cedar to maintain its original color, plan on periodic staining or sealing, especially in sun-exposed areas.
Is Cedar Right for Your Hamptons Home?
Cedar shake roofing and siding remain iconic choices for Hamptons architecture for good reason. They offer rich character, natural performance benefits, and a design aesthetic that instantly elevates a home’s exterior. However, cedar is best suited for homeowners who understand and are comfortable with the ongoing maintenance it requires.
If you’re seeking the following, cedar shake may be the perfect fit:
An authentic, coastal Hamptons look
A premium exterior upgrade
Natural materials that enhance curb appeal
A design that complements both traditional and modern homes
Bonac Builders works with a wide range of exterior materials, including cedar, fiber cement, wood siding, and other high-performance options. Whether you're refreshing your siding or planning a full exterior transformation, choosing the right material is the first, and most important, step. Request a consultation today!